Showing posts with label Philippine House of Representatives. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Philippine House of Representatives. Show all posts

Tuesday, January 6, 2026

Reforming the Party List System

 

                                                     

The year 2025 was rainy in the Philippines which resulted in massive floodings in Metro Manila. Investigations revealed that corruption in flood control projects aggravated the sufferings of people because of substandard, overpriced and ghost projects. There were allegations of commission received by legislators on projects worth billions of pesos. With that amount, those accused politicians are believed to have earned big money that could make an ordinary Filipino an instant multi-millionaire. As an example, a billion-peso project with just 10% commission will yield 100 million pesos earnings!

The scandals angered people and galvanized them so that thousands in various walks of life took to the streets in Metro Manila and some parts of the country. They asked for accountability to those who are involved in corruption and the government to take the necessary measures to stop or minimize corruption. Other issues they brought up included the constitutionally mandated but long taken for granted political anti-dynasty law and along with it the reform of the party list system. In this blog I shall focus more on the party list reform which is my main topic.

Under the previous Philippine constitutions there were only representatives elected from electoral districts. That set up was good enough for legislature. However, in1987, the framers of the new constitution introduced a novel concept in Philippines congress that was the party list. Under that system members of congress should consist of district and party list representatives. Originally, congress should be composed of 250 members with 20% of that coming from the Party list. The concept of the party list was to give the marginalized and underrepresented sectors of the society a voice in congress.  

In the beginning, candidates including those from the leftist groups were elected through the party list without issues from the public. But later, some dynastic politicians, business and influential religious groups also set their eyes on the party list. Their desire came to a head in 2013 when the Supreme Court ruled that party list representatives should not necessarily belong to the parties or groups they claim to represent. That ruling opened the doors for dynastic families and other interested groups to infiltrate the party list.

Although not all the representatives from the party list come from political dynasties and elites, many of them are.  A 2025 study by election watchdog Kontra Daya found that 86 of the 156 accredited party list groups in 2025 were linked to political dynasties and big business corporations.

The adoption by the country of the party list system is not an ideal experience because it does not serve the purpose to which it was originally intended. Instead, it is exploited by powerful political dynasties, business groups, and religious groups using their fronts to further enrich and empower them.

As an offshoot of the flood control scandal and the resulting people’s clamor for justice and reforms, there is a big possibility that the anti-political dynasty law will be passed in the 20th congress; and it is hoped that it will be implemented in the 2028 elections and the succeeding 21st congress. At present Senator Paolo “Bam” Aquino IV filed Senate Bill 1559 which is called the “Party List Reform Act”.     

In the bill the COMELEC is mandated to thoroughly vet the parties or groups who wish to be elected through the party list to ensure their authenticity, and that the nominees should truly belong to the sectors or parties they claim to represent. In addition, the nominees should not be related within the third degree of consanguinity to incumbent elected government officials or connected to government funded infrastructure projects as a contractor or as an officer of a company building the projects. The passing of the bill plus the Anti-Political Dynasty Law will hopefully improve the country’s political and electoral situations and usher economic prosperity.

A system that is deviated from its original purpose for the benefit of those who should be excluded from it needs to be reformed so that it would not become a burden to our political system. Keeping it defies logic and insults our common sense. The other alternative is to abolish it. However, doing so is difficult because the system is embedded in the constitution. 

Tuesday, December 18, 2012

The Passage of RH Bill: Has the Catholic Church Become Irrelevant?

Pres. Benigno Aquino III


The Philippine Senate and the House of Representatives passed the Reproductive Health (RH) Bill on third and final reading in the evening of December 17, 2012. A joint senate and house bicameral committee will reconcile their respective versions of the bill, and it becomes a law after President Benigno Aquino III signs it.

The passage of the bill is hoped to usher a better future for Filipino families and put into rest one of the most contentious issues that has divided the Filipinos. Introduced in 1995, the bill has been languishing in congress for 13 years because lawmakers feared of a Catholic backlash. The Catholic Church has been campaigning for its passage and reaching out to its faithful to oppose it.

Proponents of the RH bill said it contains provisions that are pro-life, pro- women and anti-poverty that will provide Filipinos sexual education, maternal care and access to modern methods of family planning with government support.                                                                                                           

For his support of the RH Bill, President Benigno Aquino III has been the object of criticism especially from the Catholic Church which views the bill as anti-life and immoral because the use of contraception kills a fertilize egg which the church considers as a human life. But Aquino said that family planning will not be forced on the couples who do not want it. Family planning and spacing of children will be a matter of couples’ own choice. However, those couples who seek support in connection with family planning will be helped by government such as giving them free contraceptives.   

Those people who are against the RH bill attributed its passage on the endorsement of the president and his certification that the bill is urgent. Many Filipinos including the Roman Catholics view the bill as a necessity whose time has come. They see the burgeoning population of the Philippines, the 39th most populated country on earth and the lack of appropriate measure on family planning as hindrance to the country’s economic progress.                   

The voting of the RH Bill by the lawmakers is indicative of the thinking and sentiment of many Filipinos on the issue. And they are not one with the church on it. Overpopulation, poverty, ignorance and women’s and child care are matters that cannot be addressed by the Catholic Church’s emphasis on the moral and spiritual dimension of the issue alone. Sexual education of couples, access to modern method of family planning and government support can help couples raise a family that is within their means to support its basic needs such as the education of their children.

The passage of the bill however, is not a rejection of the Catholic Church by its faithful. Although it failed to get the support of the majority of the lawmakers to support the bill, the Catholic Church and its leaders are still treated with high respect by some people including those who voted in favor of the RH Bill. For them, the church is just doing what it is supposed to do.                                                                                                                                                                       

Filipinos still look up to the Catholic Church as one of their vanguards against government abuses and corruption and in other matters where spiritual and moral issues on government policies are involved. Despite the criticism leveled against it, the Catholic Church has been instrumental in the ouster of past presidents who were perceived to be tyrant and corrupt. The church is also a consistent advocate for free and honest election and the defender of the rights of the poor. It is a fact that the church and its leadership have contributed to the good of the society. The late Jaime Cardinal Sin was at the forefront of leading the people against what he saw was the excesses of the Marcos regime. He was actively visible and vocal in his crusade against the administration of Marcos.  To his credit Cardinal Sin never interfered in the people’s right of suffrage. He never told his followers who to vote for during election.                                                                                                             

Although Catholics are always respectful to their church and its leaders, there are instances when their views run in conflict with the desire of their priest and bishops. A case in point is the call of some Catholic groups for a “Catholic vote” in the coming May 2013 election to penalize those lawmakers who voted for the RH Bill. In most likelihood such a move will not be heeded by most Catholics because they will most probably vote for those politicians whom they believe as the most deserving to put their trust on regardless whether they voted for or against the RH bill.